American Family Insurance reviews · page 2

4.2
23 customer reviews

Showing 11–20 of 23 reviews

Emma Watson

Smooth process from start to finish

Placed an order with American Family Insurance two weeks ago and wanted to leave my honest thoughts. The customer service was attentive, communication was crystal clear throughout the process, and the final results exceeded expectations. Exceeded my expectations on every level. They have earned a loyal customer.

3 people found this helpful

Megan Edwards Verified Buyer

Good coverage, but premium increased without filing claims

Customer support with American Family Insurance has always been courteous, but our annual renewal went up roughly 12% despite clean driving records and zero claims due to general statewide rate adjustments.

3 people found this helpful

Christopher Brooks

Acceptable, but room for better responsiveness

Decided to give American Family Insurance a try after hearing multiple recommendations. The core service met basic expectations, but communication between departments could have been much tighter. A mixed bag: solid core offering, but communication could certainly be sharper.

Matthew Anderson Verified Buyer

Average experience, decent core product

Had an interaction with American Family Insurance last week regarding an active service. The core service met basic expectations, but communication between departments could have been much tighter. Decent service overall, though I hope they streamline customer support response times.

6 people found this helpful

Chloe Nguyen Verified Buyer

Consistently reliable and great quality

Switched over to American Family Insurance earlier this year after frustration with a previous provider. Transparent pricing, skilled professionals, and a commitment to quality that is evident in every detail. Truly an industry leader. Truly refreshing to find a company that delivers exactly what they advertise.

3 people found this helpful

Andrew Thomas Verified Buyer

Exceeded my expectations on all fronts

I have been a customer of American Family Insurance for about eight months now. The customer service was attentive, communication was crystal clear throughout the process, and the final results exceeded expectations. Could not be happier with the outcome. Highly recommend them to anyone.

3 people found this helpful

Justin Collins Verified Buyer

Good digital self-service tools and card downloads

Managing proof of coverage, deductible adjustments, and paperless billing through American Family Insurance's portal is very straightforward. Good value for comprehensive coverage.

3 people found this helpful

Rachel Stewart

Adjuster assignment took over a week following storm damage

Filed a property damage claim with American Family Insurance after high winds. The intake was simple, but getting an adjuster scheduled took multiple follow-ups and seven business days.

3 people found this helpful

Ava Richardson Verified Buyer

Quick, professional, and transparent

Switched over to American Family Insurance earlier this year after frustration with a previous provider. Everything was handled with utmost professionalism. Prompt response times and honest recommendations that saved us money. Exceeded my expectations on every level. They have earned a loyal customer.

3 people found this helpful

Joshua White Verified Buyer

Dependable service, intuitive app interface

Decided to give American Family Insurance a try after hearing multiple recommendations. Reliable and high quality. The product/service works as intended and the team answered all my questions patiently. Generally very satisfied and will likely use them again when needed.

1 person found this helpful

Trust & Rating Score

4.2

Based on 23 genuine customer reviews

Select a rating to see only those reviews